Originally Posted by
ARGOJIM
I often hear this question, last weekend in fact.
A little history of the sprocket attachment over the years, first were all welded to axles, next were spiral pin through sprockets, next were keyed sprockets, next were splined sprockets no set screw holes, next and longest running had splined with set screw locating holes, next had snap ring grooves for front axles (short run), then back to previous style and finally the hd's without set screws. My assumption is the self centering ability and NOT seizing on the front axles for servicing ability.
A bush front axle bearing failure wearing tracks in the snow with the sprocket seized to the axle would be impossible ( for instance I have a few small scars from the sprocket exploding while attempting to save said sprocket from a cut off axle in a 50 ton press) leaving both you and Argo stranded ,so I assume argo's plan is let it float.
Personally I don't like it, and generally put the set screw in, as in certain situations the floating will cause a bind and or wear the sprocket and idler shaft prematurely. However I would let it float in either bush or corrosive water situations for service reasons. A quality chain will help keep it self aligned for a while or if you like shaft collars allowing some movement should do the same for alignment and serviceability.