You may have a short in the harness or the switch, Nate. The JLO connects the two kill wires together in order to short out the spark, so I'll bet it's in the switch, because even if you take both kill wires to ground on a point-fired JLO you'll usually have fire on one cylinder. 'never really figured out why that is, but I've run into it a lot. I'd pull the plug off the back of the switch and see what happens.
Good luck!
Stuck in the seventies- not in the swamp.
(6) Attex, a Hustler, a Super Swamp Fox, (2) Tricarts, (3) Tri-sports, a Sno-co trike, 3 Dunecycles, and a Starcraft! ...so far